
When I started teaching 20 years ago, I loved many of the tools and tricks other teachers shared with me. This was especially true with poetry (which was not my strong suit).
Some of those methods still work great for me today. For instance, I’ve taught the TP-CASTT method every year I’ve had freshmen (see my post on TP-CASTT here).
However, some strategies start to feel stale (at least for me) if I’ve taught them for many years. One of those is the “From Poem” structure. Don’t get me wrong: the “from poem” is a lovely poem. It’s just that after 10 years of using it, I was ready for something different. Buuuuut…I still wanted to give my students a clear format to follow, as this was something many of them needed as 9th and 10th graders.
In this post, I’ll show you my alternative lesson to the “from” poem by teaching “My Honest Poem” by Rudy Francisco.
What’s the “from” poem?
The “from” poem I’m talking about is a form poem structured after George Ellay Lyon’s poem entitled “Where I’m From.” You use the Lyon’s poem as a mentor text, and students create a similar poem about themselves.
You might also hear it called an “I am” poem. Like I mentioned, it’s a lovely poem. However, once your students get to your class, they may have already done a “from” poem many times…..or you, as the teacher, might just need to change it up for yourself!
What is “My Honest Poem”?
This poem is a contemporary example that students can also use as a mentor text for their own original poems. I like this poem as an alternative for a number of reasons. One is the fact it is a contemporary piece, and you can find clips of Rudy Francisco’s performances online. Here’s one on YouTube. There’s something powerful in seeing an author perform their own work, with the inflections they intended and the expressions they give to certain lines.
This “honest poem” does the same job as the “from” poems, but in a fresh way.
While many students may recognize the structure of a “from” poem from previous years, having a new set of criteria brings new motivation.
It’s absolutely the same format. Students use a brainstorming sheet or fill-in-the-blank worksheets to get the vibe of the poem in their own words (but it also doesn’t have to be left as strictly fill-in-the-blank).
Using a contemporary poem, specifically spoken-word poetry, opens the door to discussion of modern poetry and the opportunity to explore other poets.

Where to Begin
I always start with bell ringers or warm-ups because I find them essential for student motivation. For this lesson, I use an episode from Poetry Unbound. Poetry Unbound is a fantastic podcast where the host reads a poem and then offers his personal insights into the poem. If you listen to an episode of this podcast every day for your poetry unit, students will start to see that poetry does not have to be super academic; there is a place to just sit and talk about what you think of that poem. Essentially, Poetry Unbound works to demystify poetry. It’s a great way to open class.
After the bell ringer, I give students a handout to brainstorm. Students should fill it out and chat with each other if they need to gather information. This prompts them to think about themselves (or to interview each other about what others think of them) before they engage with the “My Honest Poem” format.

Poem Example and Discussion
Students then watch the performance of “My Honest Poem” and follow along with the full text, which you can either display or pass out to students in a printed format.
Students complete the TP-CASTT handout about the poem and, once complete, discuss the content and delivery. You can group students in a variety of ways, depending on their nature and abilities. Some classes do better with group discussions, while others work with think-pair-share groups. Students benefit by having some discussion questions available to them, such as what they noticed about the delivery and inflection of different parts of the poem. Why might the author have made the choices he did with his execution. Students may even consider the pauses and how each plays a role in conveying meaning.
Students Then Write Their Own
At this point, you can have students continue working on their brainstorming handout to write a personal version of Francisco’s poem. Students may not finish in the same class period, so they may finish for homework or in class the next day. It’s important that students have ample time to work on not only mimicking the structure of the original but also thinking about how to make it personal to them. Where can they put their own spin? What honest things about themselves do they want to think about before sharing it?

Ways to Differentiate
Emergent learners or ESOL students may benefit from listening/watching the poem performed multiple times: the first time to just enjoy it, the second time to read the lyrics while watching, and the third time to watch and make notes regarding the delivery.
When students transition to writing their own poems in this form, break down each step from brainstorming to writing to editing, and check in with students individually throughout the process. Often, this group of students does exceptionally well on this type of assignment because they can let their creativity shine while following a clear structure.
If you have honors or advanced students, challenge them to use some of the same strategies in their poems that Francisco does in his–specifically his play on words and use of rhyme. Advanced learners should also plan how they will deliver their poems, considering the inflection and pauses. You can even host a poetry cafe for your students (or at least volunteers) to perform their honest poems.

Free Downloads
Below, you can grab your own copy of the handouts and lesson plan for this lesson! Enjoy!
Brainstorm Handout My Honest Poem
Student Template For Drafting the Honest Poem
Poetry Cafe Assignment Handout
Read More On Poetry Instruction
This post is part of a series of blog on teaching poetry at the high school level. For more reading, check out: National Poetry Month Activities for Secondary ELA.
Interested in grabbing an entire done-for-you poetry unit? Try out the English Teacher Vault for only $1 today, and get access to our complete poetry unit as well as full curricula for 9th-12th grade English!

